The Risk Management Tool Box Blog

Speed Fines Shown to Increase Accidents

Graham Marshall - Monday, April 30, 2012

In 2009 State Senator Leland Yee authorized legislation which approved the doubling of traffic infringement fines on four of San Francisco's busiest roads.

The four roads involved in the special legislation included 19th Avenue, Van Ness Avenue, Lombard Street and Park Presidio Boulevard.  The first three roads form State Highway 1 and US Highway 101 as they pass through San Francisco.

But after two years of implementation, the outcome of the doubling of traffic fines In San Francisco has been a significant increase in both traffic accidents and injuries.

The San Francisco Examiner (Sunday April 15th, 2012) reporting on information released by the SF Police Departed shows:

+    68 per cent increase in traffic injuries on 19th Avenue;

+    281 per cent increase in traffic injuries on Lombard Street; and

+   122 per cent increase in traffic injuries on Park Presidio Boulevard. 

Only Van Ness Avenue reported a drop with traffic injuries falling by just 7 per cent.

The San Francisco results are a further example of the lack of evidence that imposing speed fines result in improved safety for road users.

In Perth (WA), the Road Safety Council and Western Australian Government are still trying to con WA motorists that the speed fines are anything other than a road tax on motorists.  Over here in Australia, it's nothing more than revenue raising wrapped up as a "safety campaign".

San Francisco shows the rot at the heart of the road safety campaign in WA!




Post has no comments.
Post a Comment

Captcha Image

Trackback Link
Post has no trackbacks.

Recent Posts


BP Hazard Awareness Occupational Overuse Syndrome Catostrophic Disaster Energy Model of Hazards Fire Prevention Procedures Excavations OHS Law Safety Management Program US OSHA one per center Safety Alert Nanotechnology Working at height Call Centers Walking Safety Moment Fatigue Management Kellogg Joint Venture WorkSafe WA Hazard Spotting Contract Risk Management Workplace bullying Radiation Sources Behaviour-based Safety (BBS) Unconventional Gas Safety Culture Survey Health NOPSA Global Harmonized System Raspberry Ketones Scam Water Corporation Work in Confined Spaces NORM Safety Awards Hierarchy of Safety Control Process Hazard Management Road Transport Risk Management Psycho-social Hazards Hess NOPSEMA PPE Manufacturing Total Safety Information Posters Shale Gas Santos Unconventional Oil Shell HSE Leadership UK HSE SPE HSE Innovation Award Electrical hazards Drilling Rail Safety Slips, trips and falls Job Safety Analysis Farm safety Incident Investigation Newfield WA Resources Safety Isolation Control Construction Safety Save our Seafarers Campaign TK Shipping ENI Australia Australian OSH Codes of Practice Office Safety Risk Assessment Marine Safety Safety PowerPoint Presentation IFAP Emergency Response Best bars in the oil patch LOTO Pollution prevention Oil Spill Response Sakhalin Energy Aviation Safety Toolbox talk Safe Operating Procedure (SOP) Ladder Safety Customer Testimonial Coal Seam Gas Working with explosives Railway Safety Procedure Training Course Thank God it's Friday WMC Resources Driving Safety Nautronix Unconventional Hydrocarbons APPEA BHP Billiton Bio-hazards Crane lifts Kinetic Energy Salute to Our Hero's MSDS Manual handling ALARP Mining Management of Change Situational Awareness Safety Conference Rosedale Abbey Risk Tool Box Woodside Safety "one per-center's" CSB OSHA Safety Video Supervision Social Responsibility Chevron Natural Hazard Hydraulic Fracturing ("fracking") Safe at Home Hazardous Substances Hot work Hospital Safety


Blog / Terms of Use / Site Map / Disclaimer / Risk Management Tool Box 2009. All rights reserved. Web design by Luminosity. E-Commerce by JStores.